God of War creator says AAA games are becoming worse due to over-emphasis on storytelling

If you know David Jaffe, you know how outspoken he can be, and he just published one of his more introspective takes yet. In a new video, the original God of War director argues that the AAA industry spent two decades chasing prestige as a storytelling medium, and that this chase is a big part of why studios are shutting down and projects are getting axed today.

His reasoning is somewhat personal, too. He says that after the first God of War hit in 2005, he became "the flavor of the year," courted by agents who wanted to sign him. Looking back, he calls that entire chapter, the PS2 through PS4 era AAA gaming, a delusion built on the idea that games needed to be cinematic to be taken seriously. He's careful to say the games from that stretch were genuinely great as products; he's just skeptical that the story was ever the reason they worked, a notably different tone from him defending Starfield's narrative last year.

Recent bestseller lists are dominated by mechanics-driven, multiplayer-heavy titles, not narrative epics. He points to where the audience spends its time now: Roblox, Call of Duty, Fortnite, the "virtual skate parks" of gaming rather than anything resembling a linear story.

He even compares it to music, arguing that a real art form's structure survives generational shifts, and that games chasing cinema never had that staying power. Naughty Dog's own team has pushed back on this exact argument before, pointing to The Last of Us as proof that games can land real emotional weight.

4

Subjectively, I don't think he's wrong, at least not entirely. There's a growing pile of AAA releases that feel like movies wearing a controller as a costume, long stretches of walking and talking broken up by the occasional quick-time prompt to remind you it's technically a game.

It's a fair criticism, and Jaffe isn't the only one making it. That said, calling the whole narrative era a wasted mirage swings too far the other way. Plenty of story-heavy games hit because mechanics and narrative reinforced each other, not despite the story but through it.

4

Frequently Asked Questions

TweakBot answers common questions about this news using TweakTown's own coverage from this page and related content from our archive. Tap a question to reveal the answer, or type your own below.

Question #1

Which current games or platforms does the article cite as examples of where audiences are spending time instead of narrative AAA titles?

The article cites Roblox, Call of Duty, Fortnite, and the "virtual skate parks" of gaming as examples of where audiences are spending time instead of narrative AAA titles.

Answered

Question #2

How does the article contrast mechanics-driven multiplayer hits with cinematic single-player games in terms of market performance?

The article says recent bestseller lists are dominated by mechanics-driven, multiplayer-heavy titles rather than narrative epics, noting players spend time in Roblox, Call of Duty, Fortnite and other sandbox or live-service experiences. It argues the market is rewarding sandbox and live-service formats over prestige cinematic single-player games, which are no longer where most of the money and engagement are concentrated.

Answered

Question #3

How does the article describe the evolution of AAA storytelling from the PS2/PS3/PS4 era to today, according to Jaffe?

Jaffe says the PS2 through PS4 era was a delusion built on the idea that games needed to be cinematic to be taken seriously, and he is skeptical that story was ever the main reason those games worked. He argues the industry has shifted toward mechanics-driven, multiplayer and sandbox experiences where audiences spend time on Roblox, Call of Duty, Fortnite and similar "virtual skate parks," rather than linear narrative epics. He contends that games chasing cinema never had the staying power of a real art form and that the market now rewards sandbox and live service formats over prestige single-player storytelling.

Answered

Question #4

How does the article characterize Naughty Dog’s response or pushback to the idea that cinematic storytelling is declining?

The article says Naughty Dog pushed back on that argument by pointing to The Last of Us as proof that games can deliver real emotional weight. It frames their response as a direct challenge to the claim that cinematic storytelling in games is in decline.

Answered

Have a question not listed here? Ask below and TweakBot will answer it.

Your questionAsk

Answering your question×

TweakBot is analyzing your question…

Could not get an answer

TweakBot is generating an answer

Read More

Was TweakBot helpful?Thanks for the feedback!

His blaming single-player games for layoffs and studio closures is hard to get behind. Between the studio closures and layoffs hitting Xbox and Ubisoft this year, plus a market clearly rewarding sandbox and live service formats over prestige single player, Jaffe's read on where the money is headed isn't unreasonable. I think AAA storytelling disappearing entirely is less certain; it's probably headed toward leaner and more selective rather than gone altogether.