Technology content trusted in North America and globally since 1999
8,254 Reviews & Articles | 62,625 News Posts

Autonomous Mercedes programmed to sacrifice pedestrians

Their self-driving car will be programmed to save the driver and the passengers, and not the pedestrians
By: Lana Jelic | Technology in Vehicles News | Posted: Oct 17, 2016 7:21 pm

During the past two weeks, I ran two polls about self-driving cars. In the first one, I asked whether you would you put your trust in a self-driving car and 69% of the voters said yes. The second poll was a bit trickier and contained one of the biggest issues and moral dilemmas related to the self-driving cars - if an accident is inevitable, who should the self-driving car 'sacrifice' - the passengers or pedestrians? 53% of the voters think the pedestrians should be sacrificed to save the passengers, which is much lower percentage than the recent study showed. In that study, the participants got the same question, and 75% of the voters decided to sacrifice pedestrians for the well-being of the passengers.




There is also a question of who would spend money on a self-driving car which isn't designed to protect its driver and passengers.


If you ask Mercedes-Benz, they don't have that dilemma. Their self-driving car will be programmed to save the driver and the passengers, and not the pedestrians. That's the decision they are going to stick with and implement in they upcoming Level 4 and Level 5 autonomous cars. Instead of worrying about ethics, Mercedes will program its cars to save the driver and its passengers at all costs and in every situation.


Let's say the car is spinning out of control. It's going to hit something for sure. The car is on a course to hit a crowd at the bus station, where there are kids. It can correct its course, but it will kill cyclists for sure. What does it do? For Mercedes, there is only one answer - hit whichever is less likely to hurt the driver. That could mean killing more people by running into the crowd, killing children, but so be it.




"If you know you can save at least one person, at least save that one. Save the one in the car. If all you know for sure is that one death can be prevented, then that's your first priority," company's manager of driverless car safety, Christoph von Hugo von Hugo told Car and Driver in an interview.


Mercedes confirmed that this is a difficult decision but also an important hypothetical dilemma which the industry has to resolve.




With the development of the autonomous vehicles, it is certain that every manufacturer will have such a serious dilemma. But it is also important to point out that autonomous vehicles will save millions of lives caused by careless or drunk drivers. The statistic is quite terrifying. Nearly 1.3 million people die in road crashes each year, and as many as 50 million are injured.


Autonomous vehicles will also come into dangerous situations where the immediate reaction is crucial. But they will not have our human flaws. They won't hesitate, they won't be tired or have a glass too many...


Related Tags

Got an opinion on this news? Post a comment below!