Technology content trusted by users in North America and around the world.
4,957 Articles | 29,932 Posts
Select Your Edition:  
Tweakipedia
A wealth of
tech information!

TRENDING NOW: Xbox One - Just what is Microsoft thinking?!
USA EditionYou are located: Home > All News > Business, Financial & Legal News > Samsung's legal team make iBooBoo in Apple vs. Samsung case, publicly release inadmissible evidence from trial

Samsung's legal team make iBooBoo in Apple vs. Samsung case, publicly release inadmissible evidence from trial

By: (more) | Business, Financial & Legal News | Posted: Aug 1, 2012 4:16 am

The Apple vs. Samsung trial is underway at the moment, and it looks like Samsung's legal team have made a pretty bad move, with the team in trouble with Southern District Court Judge Lucy Koh. Samsung have been going on about the 'Sony-style' design mockups this week, and this is what has landed them in trouble.

 

samsung_s_legal_team_make_ibooboo_in_apple_vs_samsung_case_publicly_release_inadmissible_evidence_from_trial

 

There were some mockups from Apple designer Shin Nishibori that were designed in order to show how Sony's design sensibilities could be melded with Apple's, in order to create a phone. The design was said by Samsung to exemplify that Apple were working from another company's designs when they were creating the iPhone, which is exactly what Apple are accusing Samsung of.

 

Apple then pulled out a prototype predating Nishibori's design that dated back to 2005, where they argued that Sony designs were just a riff on what it had done before. At this point, it had negated Samsung's point, in the eyes of Judge Koh. Koh then ruled that Samsung could not present evidence related to these 'Sony-style' designs, or another prototype design that Samsung says it was working on in 2006.

 

samsung_s_legal_team_make_ibooboo_in_apple_vs_samsung_case_publicly_release_inadmissible_evidence_from_trial

 

The picture above, as you can see, predates the iPhone, and looks very close to what Apple finalised in the iPhone design. These pictures are all part of the court filings that both parties had made earlier in the week. Samsung were trying to make a clear point here, which is that they were working on an 'iPhone-style-phone', before the actual iPhone was ever released. The statement references the F700 phone that Samsung announced all the way back in December of 2006, before the iPhone was released.

 

That, along with the prototype above, says Samsung should have been enough to prove that the company didn't copy the iPhone, said Samsung. Samsung added that "the excluded evidence would have established beyond doubt that Samsung did not copy the iPhone design," where they also added that "fundamental fairness requires that the jury decide the case based on all the evidence".

 

Judge Koh basically said no, so the legal team released the documents online. Judge Koh was pissed, big time, with AllThingsD reporting she said:

 

Tell [Samsung lawyer] Mr. Quinn I'd like to see him today. I want to know who drafted the press release, who authorized it from the legal team.

 

Where to from now will be interesting, but I do get where Samsung is coming from.


SOURCE #1

Related Tags



News Gallery

Further Reading: Read and find more Business, Financial & Legal news at our Business, Financial & Legal news index page.

TweakTown News RSS FeedDo you get our news RSS feed? Get It! Got a news tip? Tell Us!

Post a Comment about this news



Check out our
RSS feeds!
  • Upcoming Content: MSI Z77A-GD65 Gaming Series (Intel Z77) Motherboard Review
  • Upcoming Content: HGST Travelstar 7K1000 1TB 2.5" Hard Drive Review
  • Upcoming Content: Western Digital My Passport Edge for Mac 500GB External HDD Review
  • Upcoming Content: PQI Air Card 4GB Wi-Fi SDHC Review
  • Upcoming Content: LaCie CloudBox 1TB Personal NAS Review
  • Upcoming Content: Star Trek: The Next Generation - Season Three (1989) Blu-ray Review
  • Upcoming Content: The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012) Blu-ray Movie Review
  • Upcoming Content: Whatever happened to Comodo Time Machine?
  • Upcoming Content: SuperSpeed RamDisk Plus 11 Software Review
  • Upcoming Content: ADATA DashDrive Elite UE700 USB 3.0 Flash Drive Review
  • Upcoming Content: MyDigitalSSD BP4 240GB mSATA Review


Business, Financial & Legal News Posts

View More Business, Financial & Legal News Posts


TweakTown Web Poll

Question: What new stuff are you most excited to see at Computex Taipei 2013?

Cases, Coolers & PSU’s

CPU's

Gadgets

GPU's & Video Cards

Keyboards & Mice

Laptops, Tablets & Phones

Motherboards & Chipsets

New Tech

SSD's & Memory

Booth Babes

or View the Results

View More Polls

Forum Activity

View More Forum Posts

Business, Financial & Legal Press Releases

View More Business, Financial & Legal Press Releases