Popping textures and popping heads
Testing the game has proven to be quite the challenge, and the fact that DX12 is not so friendly with too many overlays for counting frames or frame times makes it quite difficult. In this case, the program called Action! was used to record the framerate, as it's the only one available. Framerate is stuck at 60FPS unless you have a 120Hz monitor, a consequence of using UWP at the moment. To test 1080p, I ended up having to borrow both a FreeSync and G-Sync monitor to test, hence the delay in getting the results to you.
Let's take a look at how it runs at 1080p. Remedy themselves have even warned that there's a large performance hit when selecting this resolution, perhaps due to that up sampling tech they use, which happens to work great on the Xbox One, but doesn't quite do anything but take up resources here.
The rumors are indeed true; the resolution is actually up sampled from 720p, and it looks atrocious. But performance at least is acceptable and smooth. Stuttering was only present on NVIDIA cards, however. If this is a result of a performance hit, then I'm curious as to how it plays when whatever mechanism is in play is taken out. It doesn't play terribly, by any means, but it is lacking.
It does look good, but the great special effects don't warrant not being able to play at higher than 60FPS on some cards. Interestingly, AMD has a good showing here, and NVIDIA isn't doing so hot. Even the Titan X is struggling quite a bit to maintain, easily being bested by a Fury X with considerably less VRAM. Maybe 1440p will even things out.
At 1440p, we still see the same advantage for AMD as we did at 1080p. The stuttering continues to be a problem on NVIDIA hardware, even if slightly but the game does look much better at this resolution than at 1080p.
Textures are sharp, the neat time effects are very well done, and the characters look like what you'd expect an AAA game to look like. There's a clear dip in performance, but it's relative to the increase in resolution. Checking memory usage yields around 3.1GB of VRAM on the Fury X and 4.6GB on the Titan X being used. At this resolution, AMD is the clear winner.
4K sees memory usage jump up to 3.9GB for the Fury X and 6.2GB for the Titan X, meaning much more is being copied to memory, obviously from the increase in resolution like this. We also see our framerate dip into something absolutely unacceptable as well.
It's unplayable, unless you want that cinematic feel and can handle your action games is small doses. It's good looking, though, quite possibly one of the best-looking ports to date.
There is something odd afoot that you wouldn't quite expect from a game that's been adamantly ported over to DX12. One would think that a few of the temporal effects, or even the AA methods used, would be offloaded to the compute queue, especially on the Xbox One version, which could benefit greatly from asynchronous compute. But though it's definitely DirectX 12, there doesn't seem to be anything actually being put into the compute queue at all. It's empty.
Even though AMD has quite the large advantage in all resolutions, it isn't because of asynchronous compute at all, but due to something else entirely. Taking a look at GPUView after a particularly grueling session revealed literally nothing but the render queue full, to the brim.
Regardless of how they get the work to the GPU and our screens, it still looks quite good, and though it's odd that there's little difference between 720p and 1080p, it's quite good looking at higher resolutions, and it even runs well enough to be playable at anything but 2160p.
As we said in the review itself, the gameplay is great, if the game as a whole is a bit lacking. But regardless, it runs, and even runs acceptably on AMD hardware at the moment, despite not making use of asynchronous compute. Be sure to let us know how your system runs in Quantum Break and if you see any other issues that we haven't yet.
PRICING: You can find products similar to this one for sale below.
United States: Find other tech and computer products like this over at Amazon's website.
United Kingdom: Find other tech and computer products like this over at Amazon UK's website.
Canada: Find other tech and computer products like this over at Amazon Canada's website.
- We at TweakTown openly invite the companies who provide us with review samples / who are mentioned or discussed to express their opinion of our content. If any company representative wishes to respond, we will publish the response here.