Technology content trusted in North America and globally since 1999
8,425 Reviews & Articles | 64,553 News Posts

Seagate Barracuda SSD - Rehashing Entry-Level Server Storage (Page 2)

By Chris Ramseyer from Aug 3, 2018 @ 10:00 CDT

256GB Class Performance Testing

Product Comparison

seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_1234

We pulled out usual 256GB class drives to compare to the Seagate Barracuda SSD. The top performers in this group have been the Crucial MX500 and Samsung 860 EVO. The Crucial MX300, Mushkin Triactor, and Toshiba VX500 are all older models that you may already own.

The Inland Professional SATA III is a low-cost DRAMless SSD that we tested last month. The Toshiba VX500 is also a DRAMless design.

Sequential Read Performance

seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_77
seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_78

The Phison S10 quad-core controller has always delivered superior sequential read performance. We've seen 560 MB/s queue depth (QD) 2 reads using this controller for nearly four years now regardless of flash.

Sequential Write Performance

seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_79
seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_80

We cannot say the same about writing sequential data. With planar TLC flash the S10 has poor consistency as the SLC buffer fills and flushes creating an ebb and flow effect with performance while data fights its way to the memory. The same happens with 3D TLC memory but to a lesser extent.

Sustained Sequential Write Performance

seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_81

Writing a large amount of sequential data to the drives, we see a similar performance drop point between the Mushkin Triactor (SMI SM2256 controller and planar TLC) and the Seagate Barracuda SSD. The Triactor drops to just 90 MB/s after the SLC but the Barracuda still delivers around 290 MB/s.

The new Seagate SSD wins the battle against previous generation technology but loses the overall war. With products like the new Crucial MX500 and Samsung 860 EVO running dynamic buffers that keep the write speed higher for longer, the older design has a lot to overcome.

Random Read Performance

seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_82
seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_83

The Seagate Barracuda Pro also shows lower tier performance reading random data. This metric is what makes your computer or device feel fast when moving around the operating system and loading applications. The Seagate drive delivers just 7,200 IOPS at QD1, around 30% less than we recommend today. The drive is much faster than a hard disk drive but most shoppers do not limit shopping to just one brand.

Random Write Performance

seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_84
seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_85

The Barracuda SSD shows the same issue with a small SLC buffer in the random write test that we observed in the sequential write test. The difference here is that most random writes come in bursts so you are likely never to see a random write event that lasts more than a few tens of a second under consumer workloads. You will also rarely have an event beyond queue depth 2.

70% Read Sequential Performance

seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_86
seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_87

The inconsistent and low sequential write performance hurts the Barracuda SSD's ability to handle sequential mixed data at a brisk pace.

70% Read Random Performance

seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_88
seagate-barracuda-ssd-rehashing-entry-level-server-storage_89

Slightly more concerning is the low random mixed workload performance. The Barracuda SSD is only slightly faster than the Inland Professional SATA III DRAMless SSD.

PRICING: You can find the product discussed for sale below. The prices listed are valid at the time of writing, but can change at any time. Click the link below to see real-time pricing for the best deal:

United States: The Seagate BarraCuda SSD 250GB Internal Solid State Drive - 2.5 Inch SATA 6Gb/s for Computer Desktop PC Laptop (STGS250401) retails for $48.99 at Amazon.

United Kingdom: The Seagate STGS250401 Barracuda Internal retails for £49.21 at Amazon UK.

Canada: The Seagate Barracuda SSD - Rehashing Entry-Level Server Storage retails for $89.99 CAD at Amazon Canada.

We openly invite the companies who provide us with review samples / who are mentioned or discussed to express their opinion. If any company representative wishes to respond, we will publish the response here. Please contact us if you wish to respond.

Related Tags