ICY DOCK Black Vortex MB174U3S-4SB USB 3.0 Storage Enclosure Review

Tyler tells us all about ICY DOCK's Black Vortex, a uniquely designed external storage solution, that comes at a price.

Published
Updated
Manufacturer: icydock
2 minutes & 51 seconds read time
TweakTown's Rating: 81%

The Bottom Line

While this is surely one of the most unique solutions we have seen in awhile, ICY DOCK's MB174U3S-4SB Black Vortex with all of its performance and connectivity options, does come at a price.
ICY DOCK Black Vortex MB174U3S-4SB USB 3.0 Storage Enclosure Review 99

Back in August of last year, we had the opportunity to review the Black Vortex drive cage solution. Now ten months later, we have a nearly identical product in house, though this time around ICY DOCK has added eSATA and USB 3.0 to the solution making it a full on external solution.

For those of you that enjoyed the design concept that wrapped around the original Black Vortex drive cage, you will be happy to know that ICY DOCK has went to the drawing board and redesigned that solution to be compatible with today's modern external technologies. This time around we have for the most part the same internal cage design with USB 3.0 and eSATA backing it up.

While typical solutions that would house four drives externally come with some form of RAID, this solution is JBOD only and that of course means for those using eSATA you need a card capable of port multiplying. For those wanting to use to USB 3.0, well you need not to worry, as it will work out of the box. Being that this is an ICY DOCK product their full line of EZConvert solutions are compatible with the Black Vortex.

MSRP of the ICY DOCK Black Vortex USB 3.0 / eSATA Enclosure comes in at $144.99 with a three-year warranty.

ICY DOCK Black Vortex MB174U3S-4SB USB 3.0 Storage Enclosure Review 02

Packaging for the ICY DOCK as you can see is quite colorful. We have an image of the enclosure to the right with quite a bit of marketing information to the left.

ICY DOCK Black Vortex MB174U3S-4SB USB 3.0 Storage Enclosure Review 03

Scope of delivery includes the power adapter, USB 3.0 cable and reading materials. This unit did not come with an eSATA cable.

ICY DOCK Black Vortex MB174U3S-4SB USB 3.0 Storage Enclosure Review 05

The front of the Black Vortex houses a large 120mm cooling fan along with dust filter to keep your drives cooled and clean when in use. We also have four drive mounts that do lock into position at the left.

ICY DOCK Black Vortex MB174U3S-4SB USB 3.0 Storage Enclosure Review 06

The front of the enclosure has LEDs to the right for each drives activity, while just below that you will find two switches for fan speed and LED control.

ICY DOCK Black Vortex MB174U3S-4SB USB 3.0 Storage Enclosure Review 07

The back of the unit houses the power connection to the far left, while the USB 3.0 and eSATA connections are to the right.

ICY DOCK Black Vortex MB174U3S-4SB USB 3.0 Storage Enclosure Review 11

In testing the Black Vortex, we first used our 1TB Toshiba hard drives in all four slots. Read and write came in around 197 MB/s and 194 MB/s, respectively.

ICY DOCK Black Vortex MB174U3S-4SB USB 3.0 Storage Enclosure Review 10

We then switched over to our Intel 730 SSD, to see the capabilities of the Black Vortex. As you see above, the enclosure is capable of 271 MB/s read and 258 MB/s write.

ICY DOCK Black Vortex MB174U3S-4SB USB 3.0 Storage Enclosure Review 12

To check if there was any performance loss while copying from two drives both mounted in the enclosure, we copied a 5GB file from one drive to another. Seen above, the transfer speed averaged out to 182 MB/s.

While the ICY DOCK Black Vortex doesn't have the typical aesthetics of an external enclosure, there are quite a few unique features with this solution. With it being almost a pure open-air solution, your drives are sure to stay cool and with the front mounted fan that should aide in cooling that much more. While staying true to the original Black Vortex design, the shell of this solution is comprised of metal while the trays and locks are plastic. With that said, this design has been used over two products now and has been proven to be reliable in design and we had no issues with it in our testing.

Performance, while purely not designed with SSDs in mind does do quite well. In testing, we were able to achieve 270 MB/s read and 258 MB/s write, which is more than enough for your standard platter drives, and ample enough if you so choose to install an SSD or two.

In a nutshell, the Black Vortex is a uniquely designed external solution and for those that are looking for something like this, it carries plentiful performance for hard drives with just the right build quality. Now if they could only work on the MSRP.

ICY DOCK Black Vortex MB174U3S-4SB USB 3.0 Storage Enclosure Review 100
Performance 83%
Quality including Design and Build 86%
General Features 84%
Bundle and Packaging 79%
Value for Money 72%
Overall 81%

The Bottom Line: While this is surely one of the most unique solutions we have seen in awhile, ICY DOCK's MB174U3S-4SB Black Vortex with all of its performance and connectivity options, does come at a price.

PRICING: You can find products similar to this one for sale below.

USUnited States: Find other tech and computer products like this over at Amazon.com

UKUnited Kingdom: Find other tech and computer products like this over at Amazon.co.uk

AUAustralia: Find other tech and computer products like this over at Amazon.com.au

CACanada: Find other tech and computer products like this over at Amazon.ca

DEDeutschland: Finde andere Technik- und Computerprodukte wie dieses auf Amazon.de

Tyler joined the TweakTown team in 2013 and has since reviewed 100s of new techy items. Growing up in a small farm town, tech wasn't around, unless it was in a tractor. At an early age, Tyler's parents brought home their first PC. Tyler was hooked and learned what it meant to format a HDD, spending many nights reinstalling Windows 95. Tyler's love and enthusiast nature always kept his PC nearby. Eager to get deeper into tech, he started reviewing.

Newsletter Subscription
We openly invite the companies who provide us with review samples / who are mentioned or discussed to express their opinion. If any company representative wishes to respond, we will publish the response here. Please contact us if you wish to respond.