TweakTown
Tech content trusted by users in North America and around the world
5,996 Reviews & Articles | 38,716 News Posts
TRENDING NOW: Counter-Strike gamer live streams SWAT team breach into his room

SKATE Xbox 360 Review - SKATE Xbox 360 Review Page 2

EA takes a realistic approach to skating with SKATE, but with mixed results.

| Sports in Gaming | Posted: Oct 23, 2007 4:00 am
TweakTown Rating: 7.5%      Developer / Publisher: EA

[img]skate_xb360_3[/img]To take advantage of the powerful engine,

 

SKATE utilizes both analog sticks for controlling most aspects of the game. Obviously the left stick is used to move about direction wise, but the

 

use of the right analog stick is quite unique for this genre, as it takes on the role for ollies - the fundamental building block for most skating tricks and

 

moves - as well as flip tricks. To execute these flip tricks, you flip the right analog stick according to the trick you're trying to pull off, where the
longer you hold it before launching and the quicker you do launch, the higher you go. To execute other types of moves, such as spins and grabs, the game is a

 

little simpler - just turn as normal in the air for spins, and use the shoulder triggers to grab with each hand respectively. It is also interesting to note

 

that grinding in this game (that is, sliding across ledges and rails) is actually far more simplified than we're used to in this genre, as there is no button

 

to initiate a grind and no mini-game to maintain
a grind - just land on a grind-able object with forward momentum to initiate, and the game basically maintains your balance until you're forward progression

 

stops, or until you jump out of it.


This control and trick system is really something special as it allows for so much control. In a way, SKATE simplifies the whole ollie and

 

flip/grab/grind system to the point it seems so easy in theory, but the precision and timing required in practice makes it detailed and very powerful. Even

 

though you can make do basically mashing the right analog stick, those more seriously into the game can go well beyond this into the realm of obsessively

 

mastering every move and trick around the beautifully crafted city of San Vanelona. Yes, there is absolutely no doubting that SKATE is a technical

 

[img]skate_xb360_4[/img]master piece and a downright brilliant

 

representation of the skating art form, but it comes at a price, and this price is sacrificed accessibility and playability.


Don't get me wrong, the gameplay in SKATE can be fun, but it can also be very tedious and terribly repetitive. The problem with such an open and

 

powerful control system and engine is, while it allows for masters of the game to really flourish, it also allows for less than perfect gamers to really

 

struggle as there is basically little to no assistance at all - there is no difficulty setting and no attribute points for skaters as everything is down to

 

your own abilities. Mastering the trick system,
or more specifically the flip trick system, is also extremely hard as it requires so much finesse to be able to execute a flip trick on demand even if you

 

pause the game and check the trick book, knowing exactly how to do it. This is because the game squishes a large amount of different flip tricks all onto the

 

right analog stick, so the difference between two or three tricks could be very small and near impossible to replicate on demand in the actual game.


The make matters worse, the slightest error in this game will almost always cause you to fall flat on your face, and I'm not exaggerating here - this game

 

demands darn near perfection for almost everything you do, so you can expect to fall over a lot. Sometimes it's hard to even line up a grind properly let

 

alone flip trick to manual on a table top while gapping to another table top, landing in a manual and flip tricking out of it, which is the stuff you will

 

eventually have to do if you want to
go anywhere in the career mode. It may be slightly embarrassing to admit this, but I literally spent more than one hour trying to finish a Pro Challenge much

 

like this because the probability someone like me, [img]skate_xb360_5[/img]a relative new comer to the game, could pull a series of moves like this off flawlessly was naturally very low. I can't

 

say that was the most enjoyable hour of gaming in my life - in fact, it was down right horrible.


But then comes the rush of satisfaction when you pull something like this off in SKATE, allowing you to forget all your woes, until the next one

 

anyway. When you somehow manage to create a flow of flips and grinds and grabs that you thought you could never do, it's a very sweet feeling. So sweet you

 

want to keep it on hand to show a friend when they come over and laugh at you face planting an ollie over a 2 inch gutter, which you will do plenty of times,

 

trust me. Luckily this
can be done easily enough with the game's replay editor, which can not only save replays and photos locally, but also allows you to upload them to the online

 

SKATE community for others gamers to view. As the game says, "it's fiction until you've got it on film", so the presence of a reasonably

 

detailed replay and video editor in this game is certainly a nice one.


To coincide with the game's down to earth approach, SKATE features reasonably impressive graphics which itself has a very realistic and gritty

 

feel. The city of San Vanelona is rendered nicely with a lot of atmosphere and character, as you'd expect from a city riddled with skate culture, but at the

 

same time you never get the impression the city was modeled exclusively for the skater in mind which adds to the game's creativity. When EA first released

 

screenshots for this game some time ago
I recall cringing at the presence of a vignetting effect on the screen during gameplay at all times but it actually comes off quite well

 

when you see it first hand, somehow adding to the game's realistic feel. The only complaint I can muster with the visuals is the game's camera view, which is

 

mostly fine but its 'low and slightly to the side angle' approach can sometimes make precision landing, such as aiming for skinny rails, quite challenging.

 

To complete the aesthetics, the sound in this game is also quite
top notch, particularly the sound effects associated with skating on different surfaces, further adding to the game's realistic feel.


SKATE is a very well made and unique game that oozes quality and attention to detail, but at the same time I have to wonder just how appealing this

 

is to the mainstream gamer, who may not have the patience or passion for skating to not only put up with the game's initial learning curve but also its

 

general complexity that will take hours and hours to even come close to properly mastering. On one hand you really have to commend EA for a title such as

 

this as I'm sure there are plenty of
gamers out there who would go giddy for such an awesome representation of skating, but on the other hand there mustn't be but a handful of games ever made

 

that are more frustrating and demanding when it comes to perfection as SKATE is, and it can really put you off. I dunno, maybe I'm just not cut out

 

for SKATE like I'm not cut out for real skating, but if this is the case, I doubt I'm alone. You can't blame EA for wanting to take on a niche area of

 

the skating genre considering the stranglehold
Activision have on pick-up and play arcade fun with the Tony Hawk series, but this ultimately means SKATE won't be for everybody. Still though,

 

I can't bring myself to giving SKATE an average score because it is really much more than just an average every day game.

Xbox 360 Elite Console

 

Right of Reply

We at TweakTown openly invite the companies who provide us with review samples / who are mentioned or discussed to express their opinion of our content. If any company representative wishes to respond, we will publish the response here.

Further Reading: Read and find more Gaming content at our Gaming reviews, guides and articles index page.

Do you get our RSS feed? Get It!

Got an opinion on this content? Post a comment below!

Latest Tech News Posts

View More News Posts
Check out TweakTown Polls on LockerDome on LockerDome

Forum Activity

View More Forum Posts

Press Releases

View More Press Releases