TweakTown
Tech content trusted by users in North America and around the world
6,002 Reviews & Articles | 38,746 News Posts
TRENDING NOW: Intel's Core i7-5960X CPU has already been overclocked to 6.2GHz

Test Drive Unlimited PC Review - Test Drive Unlimited PC Review page 2

The PC finally sees TDU after a few months of waiting, although Atari should have perhaps waited a little longer.

| Racing in Gaming | Posted: May 22, 2007 4:00 am
TweakTown Rating: 7.5%      Developer / Publisher: Eden Games

To get a real challenge racing wise from TDU, you'll probably want to go online and it is here that TDU again really impresses, but also falls short.

 

First of all, lets address the good news - the online "mode" in TDU is so seamless to the entire game, that it isn't a separate mode at all. When

 

you create your profile, you are given the option of linking it to a Gamespy account. If you don't do this, your profile will be offline only

 

permanently so choose wisely, as the game can't be 100% finished
with an offline profile. This is because the main game mode in TDU can be both offline and online, and as you browse around your map and drive around

 

Hawaii, you'll see both offline and online races. On top of this, other gamers online will drive by, and you can challenge them right there and then with a

 

flick of the headlights. You can also access online clubs, user made challenges, and compare your times and scores with a world wide leader board all with a

 

few clicks of the mouse.


That's the good news. The bad news is, all of this just never seems to work as you'd expect. Getting my profile to associate with my GamespyID was easy

 

enough, but once you start the game and the online components [img]tdu_pc_5[/img]kick in (after the short introductory period), things start to go a little sour. First of all, even though I'm sure there

 

are people online, sometimes you will go hours without seeing a single player driving around. When you do find one, or a preset online race with people

 

inside ready to go, I was
lucky if I ever made it past the dreaded "connection lost" message. In fact the whole time I was playing, online elements only seem to pop up

 

occasionally despite the fact the game insisted I was connected to the TDU servers. In all fairness, I am located in Australia on a modest 512K connection at

 

that, but when you can't even see people in game that the map is telling you is there, I've gotta believe something else is up.


Even if these issues can be largely attributed to my location and connection, there's no denying that, by simply looking at the leader boards, online mode

 

in TDU PC is absolute riddled with cheaters - people finishing 3 minutes races in 30 seconds, people finishing a "F Class" race with an

 

"A Class" supercar etc. It doesn't take a genius to hop onto Google and see that there are trainers out there allowing people to instantly obtain

 

millions of dollars, become super speedy and cheat the class
system. This is what happens when you merge the offline and online modes together on the PC and allow the user end machine to upload data about a user's

 

profile - people simply change the data locally before it gets sent to the TDU servers and ruin it for everyone else. This system may work on the Xbox 360

 

but not the PC, which is why I will refrain from labeling TDU as a true Massive Multiplayer Online Racer - if WoW worked off character data stored locally on

 

people's PCs, it would have died years ago.


If you can put those negatives aside though and just enjoy TDU for its incredible open nature and its fun but somewhat semi-realistic gameplay, you will

 

have a great time. The racing is fast and furious, and the depth on offer is insane - you will have hours and hours of driving in TDU just to finish the

 

game 100%, let alone after that where the PC version opens up an all new "Hardcore Mode" from the main menu, which takes the mostly arcade based

 

gameplay and puts a simulation racing spin on
things. And even though I [img]tdu_pc_6[/img]have already covered the

 

true scaled representation of Hawaii, I feel compelled to emphasis again just how cool it is - being able to drive on the amount of roads TDU has to offer is

 

mind blowing. Yep, there is no doubting that any racing fan or just PC gamers in general should have a great time with TDU.


That is until the game randomly corrupts your saved game file. After starting my second profile specifically for online use, I only managed to get

 

37% into finishing the game until the infamous corruption happened to me. For those not in the know, saved game corruption is a recognized problem with

 

TDU PC that Atari claim will be fixed in a future patch. Any previously corrupted saved game will not be restored, but future corruptions should cease

 

to exist once this patch is out, which is said
to be any day now. Luckily for me, I knew about this issue before installing TDU and regularly backed up my saved game files (found in My Documents > Test

 

Drive Unlimited on XP). Even so, this really is an unacceptable bug for a retail game and I can only imagine how many unknowing people have lost their

 

progress because of it - isn't stuff like this why TDU went through a beta testing phase? On top of this, if you lurk around the Atari community forums and

 

other locations, you'll read stories of TDU corrupting
Windows after uninstalling, saved games losing data but still being loadable, and other issues of this nature. Pretty scary stuff.


Visually, TDU is very impressive but once again the good comes with the bad. The good here is the car models look fantastic and the Hawaiian

 

environments are great, especially when you switch HDR on in the options menu. The bad here is the performance of the game, even on modest visual settings.

 

Now, the X1900XTX I run is no longer king kong of the 3D chips, but coupled with an E6600 and 2GB of memory, it should be able to handle top quality from any

 

DX9 game like TDU and in effect it does - when you add
"-fps" minus the quotes to TDU's desktop shortcut, the game will print your current frame rate at the top left corner of your screen and mine is

 

consistently hovering around a smooth 40-60fps. The problem comes with the regular stuttering whenever objects coming into your view distance are being

 

loaded, creating a reasonably undesirable "pop up" effect rather than a smooth transition from low level of detail to high

 

level of detail. Atari claim performance is another area the patch address,
but we'll have to wait and see for that one. Another slight disappointment with TDU's visuals is the time of day never changes and neither does the weather -

 

this is not a huge deal but more a chance lost to make the graphics that much more impressive.


Like any racing game, the controls are a vital part of TDU and while the keyboard will suffice, it is highly recommended you have a wheel or at least a

 

gamepad. I personally used a gamepad - the USB XB360 controller - and while it took a few minutes to configure, it worked great with TDU, featuring full

 

analog control on the sticks and the triggers for acceleration and braking, which is very important as simply flooring it in TDU is not a good idea, you

 

really have to ease your way into full throttle or otherwise
you will likely spin out or lose control. Unfortunately I could not seem to get force feedback working with the 360 controller but research suggests this is

 

possible if you use the XBCD drivers and not the official MS drivers.


Unlike the Xbox 360 version, so far the PC version has not seen any downloadable car packs despite the fact the in game menu system does have an entry for

 

it. Given the bugs and general "beta" feel of TDU PC, it would be nice to see Atari release a few free packs with the patch to try and make up for

 

some of the oversights, but there has been no official mention of this so I'm just throwing ideas out there. In any case, sooner or later you've got to think

 

someone out there will figure out how to
add user made cars so hopefully addons - official or not - are not far off.


So how does one sum up Test Drive Unlimited for the PC? It is such a brilliant concept and in most ways it is executed flawlessly to the point of

 

innovation in the racing genre, but the bugs and issues present in the retail version are so prevalent they simply can't go unnoticed. If you're lucky enough

 

to have a perfect online experience with no saved game corruptions, all without a sign of performance issues, TDU PC is easily a 9/10 or better game that

 

should be played by everyone, but the odds are you won't
be this lucky. Hopefully a patch is here soon that can put these issues behind us, as I really want to enjoy TDU PC because as far as arcade/semi-realistic racers go, I don't think there is a game out there with as much potential as TDU, it's just hard to in its current

 

state. If Atari can fix the

 

issues in the near future and maybe do something about the online cheating, then you've got a seriously fun game on your hands with Test Drive Unlimited

 

PC.

 

[img]tdu_pc_7[/img][img]tdu_pc_8[/img]

Logitech G25 Wheel

 

Right of Reply

We at TweakTown openly invite the companies who provide us with review samples / who are mentioned or discussed to express their opinion of our content. If any company representative wishes to respond, we will publish the response here.

Further Reading: Read and find more Gaming content at our Gaming reviews, guides and articles index page.

Do you get our RSS feed? Get It!

Got an opinion on this content? Post a comment below!

Latest Tech News Posts

View More News Posts
Check out TweakTown Polls on LockerDome on LockerDome

Forum Activity

View More Forum Posts

Press Releases

View More Press Releases