TweakTown
Tech content trusted by users in North America and around the world
5,911 Reviews & Articles | 38,063 News Posts

Ask the Experts Question: Which smartphone? Galaxy S4 or Nexus 5?

Question asked by Heidi from New Zealand | | Mobile Devices Content | Posted:
Ask Question | Comment | Font Size: AA

Trying to decide between Samsung GS4 9505 or Nexus 5

 

Camera and storage both big priorities for me, as well as battery talk time (I like being able to have a spare battery on hand to swap over if necessary, not so easy with the Nexus).

 

Also performance/speed is important, as well as large screen. My main phone uses are calling, email, web browsing, photos.

 

I understand that the GS4 has a 13mp camera, and the Nexus 5 only 8 but how do the sensors compare?

Hi Heidi,

 

You bring up some good points, where you require a great rear-facing camera and storage - which would have me siding on the side of Samsung's Galaxy S4... but then you also want performance and speed, which is something that the Nexus 5 does well.

 

TweakTown image asktheexperts/1/8/182_04_which_smartphone_galaxy_s4_or_nexus_5.jpg

 

I'll split this into two answers:

 

Going for the Galaxy S4: The Galaxy S4 is a great smartphone, and is something I recommend if you already own a Galaxy-branded smartphone as it won't seem like such a change. The rear-facing camera on the S4 is better than the Nexus 5, too.

 

Expandable storage is also another benefit of the Galaxy S4 versus the Nexus 5 - where you can slot in a massive 64GB microSD card and enjoy mass amounts of storage. The screen is pretty much identical to the Nexus 5, so you're not benefiting there.

 

I think Samsung's TouchWiz UI is quite bloatiful - slowing the phone down, and adding unnecessary apps to the smartphone. This slows it down considerably (especially with a bunch of widgets, etc all over your home screens).

 

On the side of the Nexus 5: Pure Android - it's beautiful. There's no special third-party UI (user interface) splashed on top. This is the way Google wants you to experience Android.

 

The Nexus 5's rear-facing camera is good, but not great. It's a gigantic leap over the Nexus 4's rear-facing snapper, but the Galaxy S4 wins here.

 

There's no expandable storage, so 32GB is all you get. But even on my Nexus 5 which I've owned since its release, I still have a few GB spare on my 16GB model and I snap photos and keep everything synced from my Google Glass on it, too.

 

What I think you should buy: The Nexus 5 is $449 AU or $477 NZD. This is a huge win for the Nexus 5, as the Galaxy S4 is at a minimum, $550+ for the 32GB model. Kogan sells the Galaxy S4 for $499 - which is ridiculously cheap, considering it is $600+ everywhere else.

 

Even then, I still recommend the Nexus 5. I think you will not be disappointed.

Related Tags

Do you get our Ask the Experts RSS feed? Get It!

- Sadly we cannot answer every question. There is a friendly community in our forums though who may well be able to help with your tech question!

Post a Comment about this Q&A

Latest Tech News Posts

View More News Posts

TweakTown Web Poll

Question: Facebook's acquisition of Oculus VR will...

Improve Oculus Rift Development

Hamper Oculus Rift Development

Completely destroy Oculus Rift Development

Let's wait and see, I'm not sure

or View the Results

View More Polls

Forum Activity

View More Forum Posts

Press Releases

View More Press Releases