TweakTown

   
Small Font
Large Font
  Home
       News
     Articles
      Guides
     Gaming
     Forums
   Daily Deals
Shopping   
              Audio Reviews Casing & Cooling Reviews CPU & Chipset Reviews Digital Lounge Guides Memory Reviews Mobile Reviews Motherboard Reviews Networking Reviews Software Reviews Storage Reviews Visual Reviews
  Search
   
   RSS Content Feeds
       



 
home > articles > memory > ddr-400 memory battle - crucial vs. geil vs. mushkin > page 2
DDR-400 Memory Battle - Crucial vs. Geil vs. Mushkin

Author: Cameron Johnson SUMMARY: Today we are comparing DDR-400 enthusiast memory modules from Crucial, Geil and Mushkin which are designed for performance AMD Athlon 64 users. After taking a look at each module and checking their compatibility on a range of DDR based chipsets, we run a bunch of benchmarks to work out which module offers the best performance.
Editor: Cameron Wilmot
Category: Memory
Published: 6th September 2005

Email this ArticlePrint out a copy of DDR-400 Memory Battle - Crucial vs. Geil vs. Mushkin

Slashdot

Rate our Content Now!

Thumbs UpThumbs Down

Crucial Ballistix

First on the chopping block is Crucial with their Ballistix memory modules.




Module Size: 2x512MB (1GB Total)
Package: Ballistix 184-pin DIMM
Feature: DDR PC4000
Configuration: 128Meg x 64
Error Checking: NON-ECC
Speed: 250MHz x2 (DDR500)
Voltage: 2.8V
Memory Timings: 3-4-4-8


The Ballistix range is Crucial’s first actual attempt at an enthusiast memory module. Ballistix is designed for ultra high clock speed by sacrificing latency times. With DDR-2 now being the preferred memory for Intel platforms, DDR is set for the AMD realm, which isn’t very happy with high latency times due to its on die memory controller.

Crucial ships the Ballistix range using gold coloured alloy heat spreaders. These spreaders are held onto the modules with metal clips and thermal tape. These spreaders are easy to remove if you wish to install copper spreaders which do tend to offer a cooler memory module due to the thermal characteristics of copper.



With the spreaders removed, we get to see the modules themselves for all their naked glory. The PCB is a 6 layer low noise black layout. Crucial uses single sided DIMS for its 256, and 512MB sticks and double sided for the 1GB and 2GB sticks. Using single sided DIMM’s are a preference with AMD systems – compatibility will be better especially if you’re using four modules in one system.



The modules from Crucial are Micron based, however, the Micron insignia has been lasered off and the Ballistix label has been installed. This means we aren’t truly able to determine the nanosecond rating these modules are rated for; however, we can assume they are the 4ns with the 4v label on them.


Compatibility

With regards to compatibility we tested the two modules in a variety of platforms that support Dual Channel DDR. We did tests on the AMD Athlon 64 platform with a 3000+ Winchester core on both K8T890 and nForce4 motherboards. We also tested them on Intel I875P and I865PE, VIA PT880 and SiS 655FX. For AMD Athlon XP we did tests on VIA KT880 and nForce 2.

All platforms accepted this memory and worked at the specified timings and in some cases slightly higher on boards that allowed native DDR-500 support.


How much does it cost?




Previous Page Page 2 of 8 Next Page


Share your thoughts
Talk about "DDR-400 Memory Battle - Crucial vs. Geil vs. Mushkin" in our forum!
Related Articles
OCZ Flex-II PC2-9200 2GB Memory Kit
Patriot Viper DDR3-1866 2GB Memory Kit
Patriot Memory PC2-9200 2GB EP DDR2 Kit
Patriot Memory PC2-6400 4GB LL DDR2 Kit
Aeneon Xtune DDR3-1333 2GB Memory Kit

Subscribe to TweakTown's Newletter!
  Preview
We will not sell or share your details

Free Technology Magazines

Virtualization Everywhere

Access our featured guide, Virtualization Everywhere, and learn how you can easily virtualize your servers without the high cost and complexity.


Latest in PC Gaming

Mass Effect PC Review
A console RPG ported to the PC - sounds scary, but Mass Effect PC was in good hands with BioWare.
Overclocked: A History of Violence PC Review
While adventure gaming is no longer the PC's finest, games like Overclocked prove there is still quality to be had.
TrackMania United Forever PC Review
United Forever offers a great way for new comers to jump right into TrackMania, but series veterans should be warned - this is not a true sequel.
Assassin's Creed Director's Cut Edition PC Review
This console original feels quite at home on PC, but most criticisms remain.
Trials 2 Second Edition PC Review
Fun, addictive, and yet extremely challenging and frustrating. Introducing the ultimate time waster, Trials 2 SE.

Copyright © 1999-2008 Tweak Town Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.
Advertising | RSS Content Feeds | Awards and Ratings | About Us | Contact Us | Legal