TweakTown

   
Small Font
Large Font
  
Normal Width
Increase Width
  Home
       News
     Articles
      Guides
     Gaming
     Forums
   Daily Deals
Shopping   
              Audio Reviews Casing & Cooling Reviews CPU & Chipset Reviews Digital Lounge Guides Memory Reviews Mobile Reviews Motherboard Reviews Networking Reviews Software Reviews Storage Reviews Visual Reviews
  Search
   
   RSS Content Feeds
       



 

home > articles > casing & cooling > athlon xp hsf mini-roundup – scythe vs. vantec vs. thermaltake > page 2
Athlon XP HSF Mini-Roundup – Scythe vs. Vantec vs. Thermaltake

Author: Mike Wright SUMMARY: Today we are comparing Athlon XP HSFs in a Mini-Roundup from Scythe with their Arctic Cooling 2L, Vantec with their AeroFlow 2 and Thermaltake with their POLO 735.
Editor: Cameron Wilmot
Category: Casing & Cooling
Published: 28th March 2004

Email this ArticlePrint out a copy of Athlon XP HSF Mini-Roundup – Scythe vs. Vantec vs. Thermaltake


Rate our Content Now!

Thumbs UpThumbs Down

Scythe Arctic Cooling 2L



Though Scythe isn’t an old name in the enthusiast community, they began making a name for themselves when they brought out the Kamakaze HSF a while back. It was a performance cooling solution that made many stand up and take notice. Their latest model appears to have moved more to aesthetics than performance, but it is still rated for processors up to the Athlon XP 3400+. It is pretty good since there isn’t a processor of this caliber available yet, but it should be able to handle the stress we’re going to put it through.



The fan of the Scythe unit is not attached in a conventional manner. Instead of being mounted with screws (allowing for us to remove it properly), it is adhered to the heatsink itself with what looks to be a silicon compound similar to what you would use in your bathroom.

The fan is an 80mm type that sits 37mm in height, mainly due to the design and lighting effects that are built in. Yes, this is a lighted fan so will set off an enclosure with a windowed side panel. The fan spins at a maximum of 2800 RPM and emits less than 24 dBA at full power. And as you can probably tell by my description, you can control the fan speed.



This is accomplished by means of a simple 3-way switch that occupies an empty PCI slot. Since I like it when manufacturers keep things simple, I was happy to see nothing more complicated than HI, MEDIUM and LOW speed settings.



The heatsink itself is made of aluminum and has a copper base melded to the bottom. While the base didn’t appear to have any flaws, it also didn’t have much of a shine either.



The clipping mechanism looks to be pretty standard fare, but it attaches at an unusual angle. With the mainboard already installed in my system, I had to attach the clip from the back side (which also has a lip for a screwdriver). There was simply no room in the case to hook it up from the proper side of the cooler. But even so, there were no issues with slippage or seating when it was installed in this manner.







Find the lowest price on Quality Heatsinks!



Previous Page Page 2 of 6 Next Page


Share your thoughts!
Talk about "Athlon XP HSF Mini-Roundup – Scythe vs. Vantec vs. Thermaltake" in our forums!



[Related Content] You may be interested in:
Cooler Master UCP 700W Power Supply
DIY Case Mods - Suitcase turned into PC
XIGMATEK HDT-SD964 CPU Cooler
Cooler Master CSX Medusa Cosmos Chassis
CrazyPC Electroluminescent Wire Kit

Subscribe to TweakTown's Newletter!
  Preview
We will not sell or share your details

Free Technology Magazines

Cabling Installation & Maintenance

Cabling Installation & Maintenance provides information to industry professionals involved in the purchase, design, installation and maintenance of premises and campus-wide cabling systems.

Latest in PC Gaming

Mass Effect PC Review
A console RPG ported to the PC - sounds scary, but Mass Effect PC was in good hands with BioWare.
Overclocked: A History of Violence PC Review
While adventure gaming is no longer the PC's finest, games like Overclocked prove there is still quality to be had.
TrackMania United Forever PC Review
United Forever offers a great way for new comers to jump right into TrackMania, but series veterans should be warned - this is not a true sequel.
Assassin's Creed Director's Cut Edition PC Review
This console original feels quite at home on PC, but most criticisms remain.
Trials 2 Second Edition PC Review
Fun, addictive, and yet extremely challenging and frustrating. Introducing the ultimate time waster, Trials 2 SE.

Copyright © 1999-2008 Tweak Town Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.
Advertising | RSS Content Feeds | Awards and Ratings | About Us | Contact Us | Legal