Users looking for a more durable HDD for their NAS units desire as much reliability and performance as possible. Looking to a higher-tier HDD is a natural progression for those in the market for the best performance and reliability.
While the Red has plenty of durability, and is geared for demanding NAS workloads, the longer warranty period and resilience to heavier workloads will attract many to the WD Se. The higher spindle speed of the Se has the side effect of higher power consumption, but to users with more demanding workloads, this can be an acceptable trade-off for the increased performance.
You simply cannot get around the fact that most NAS units, especially in the 1-5 bay category, are constrained to the limit of a single gigabit Ethernet port. A single gigabit Ethernet port is limited to an effective speed of 120-125 MB/s. The sequential speeds we received from the RAID 0 array were in the 550-600 MB/s range from both arrays, which easily outstrips the speed of the Ethernet connection.
Where the real difference comes in is in multiple user environments, where all access becomes randomized. Users with heavy random access will find a large difference in performance with the faster Se series.
Most users will not be utilizing a RAID 0 in their NAS unless they dealing with replicated data protected by strong backup schemes. Even with the Red's pushing out 580 IOPS in our random tests, we have to keep in mind that is only a scant 2 MB/s. Moving up to the Se brought about gains to nearly 800 IOPS with a 4K random read workload. The gains were much higher in random read access than random writes, where we only observed an incremental increase in speed. With mixed read/write workloads, there isn't as much of a difference between the two solutions in RAID 0.
In RAID 5, the most common use case, the Se really comes into its own. With RAID 5 random write activity, the Se's blew past the Reds - it really was a no-contest. RAID 5 sequential performance is also penalized heavily for the Reds, while the Se array continued to chug along with great speed. Our tests with mixed read/write sequential workloads further illustrated the huge difference between the two solutions in RAID 5, with the Se coming out with a big win. When it came to our workload emulations, there was a much larger performance delta between the two arrays, with the Se coming away with a resounding win.
The performance was a big win for the Se where it matters, in the RAID 5 tests. The faster platter speeds and enterprise-class features shone through to win the day. Throwing an extra two years of warranty into the mix, for a total of five years, distances the Se from the Red that much more. With better reliability and performance, the Se makes a great NAS HDD for demanding environments.
PRICING: You can find products similar to this one for sale below.
United States: Find other tech and computer products like this over at Amazon's website.
United Kingdom: Find other tech and computer products like this over at Amazon UK's website.
Canada: Find other tech and computer products like this over at Amazon Canada's website.
- Page 1 [Introduction]
- Page 2 [Test System and Methodology]
- Page 3 [RAID 0 4K Random Read/Write]
- Page 4 [RAID 0 128K Sequential Read/Write]
- Page 5 [RAID 0 Database/OLTP and Fileserver]
- Page 6 [RAID 0 Emailserver and Webserver]
- Page 7 [RAID 5 4K Random Read/Write]
- Page 8 [RAID 5 128K Sequential Read/Write]
- Page 9 [RAID 5 Database/OLTP and Fileserver]
- Page 10 [RAID 5 Emailserver and Webserver]
- Page 11 [Final Thoughts]
Recommended for You
- We at TweakTown openly invite the companies who provide us with review samples / who are mentioned or discussed to express their opinion of our content. If any company representative wishes to respond, we will publish the response here.
Latest News Posts
- Crackdown 3 delayed to 2018
- MediaTek to announce new Helio processors on August 29th
- Huawei reveals the first official Mate 10 teaser
- Nokia flagship is finally here: Meet the Nokia 8
- Final Fantasy XIV subscriptions at all time high
- Synology DS1817 8-Bay NAS (Tested at 10Gbps) Review
- ASRock X399 Taichi Threadripper TR4 Motherboard Review
- Samsung Portable SSD T5 500GB and 2TB Review
- how many pcie slots can i use?
- Bios question on new build
- Optimize system performance with new drive adapter
- Lian Li reveals new PC-Q39 tempered glass Mini-ITX tower
- Longsys' world-first 11.5x13mm NVMe BGA SSD drives new mobile user experience
- Thermaltake attends NVIDIA Gamer Connect
- ASRock introduces the X10 IoT router for smart homes